
Photo by me'nthedogs
An interesting post from Time Magazine’s blog The Curious Capitalist gives a few observations of how they think life will play out after the bubble:
“By the time we’re done here this is going to be equivalent to the big recessions of the past,” says Harris. “Similar to the recessions of 1974 and 1982.” That’s a lot better than a rerun of the Great Depression. But it still means big-time job losses, and lots of painful retrenchment for consumers and business.
This is not, yet, a unanimously held opinion. There is even still some debate over whether this even is a recession. But I’m thinking that’s going to fade away soon. “All my cousins already know we’re in a recession,” says Bob Barbera, chief economist at ITG and, coincidentally, a former Lehman chief economist. “You need a Ph.D in economics to have a debate about it.” Barbera thinks that, “in the fullness of time,” it will be apparent that the recession began in autumn 2007.
Barbera also believes this recession will end early next year, which is a nice thought. But what comes afterward probably won’t feel so great either. “I’d be very surprised to see a strong recovery in the economy,” says Harris. “The consumer was being spurred along by two big booms, housing and the stock market, and this expansion of debt.” No more. “You’ve got a much more conservative consumer in the next decade,” he says.
This is what the aftermath of an epic credit bubble looks like. For the financial sector, never very good at retrenching in an orderly fashion, it’s a time fraught with risk of collapse. But even if collapse is averted, the bubble still has to deflate. And it is deflating: Household debt, which grew at double-digit rates from 2002 through 2006, rose at just a 1.4% pace in the second quarter, according to data released Thursday by the Federal Reserve. This is, for the long-run financial health of Americans, a good thing. It just means there won’t be much economic fun anytime soon.
I think they are correct that the attitudes of consumers will change. People will not buy as much now that the job market is depressed, the credit industry is in danger, the stock market is down, and the housing sector is troubled. Truthfully, attitudes will change because consumers have no more places to pull out cash and use as an ATM. Good luck trying to get a lender to give you an unending supply of credit, they’re all working hard themselves to hoard cash so they won’t go under. At the same time if your house isn’t worth as much as before, you can’t expect to refinance it and get a wad of cash. The stock market will take a few years to recover so there’s no money there either. With all their previous lines of credit cut off, the consumer has nothing to do but to sit idly on their hands until things get turned around.
I believe this is the silver lining to the recent chaos: the American consumer is being forced to learn fiscal responsibility. It is definitely a good thing that the rate of household debt is deflating, falling from double-digit growth to a measly 1.4%. There was no way consumers could have kept up that growth when their real wages were not growing as fast without declaring bankruptcy. I think this was the rude awakening that was needed to prevent economic collapse of the average American household. And it couldn’t have come any sooner.